Archive for the ‘ Opinion ’ Category

Walters claim for starting role hard to ignore

Ireland 1 (Cox, 86) – Czech Republic 1 (Baros, 50)

Simon Cox and James McClean will emerge as the headline names from an underwhelming 1-1 draw against the Czechs, but it was another assured performance from Jonathan Walters that should really grab the limelight. The Stoke City man appeared from the bench with 20 minutes remaining and his strength, intelligence and movement immediately transformed the Irish attack. His first touch of the game set up Paul Green to work the goalkeeper, his next created an opening for Andrews and for the remainder his work rate and positioning was such as to make the often directionless long ball tactic look like a viable means of picking the lock. Cox will take the plaudits, but it was the presence of Walters as the focal point of Ireland’s attack which provided the foothold in the final third from which the goal came. Continue reading

On Friday

When you surrender to what is and so become fully present, the past ceases to have any power. You do not need it anymore. Presence is the key. Now is the key.”

– Eckhart Tolle

(Recommended reading: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kfVsfOSbJY0)

This essay seeks to trace the diverse philosophical influences and spiritual insights expounded in ‘Friday’, Rebecca Black’s acclaimed critique of the Kantian theory of time as a necessary category of experience, modern ennui and the Existential plight. Drawing on the wealth of Eastern spiritual philosophy as well as Christian theology and morality, Black’s arguments touch on responses to the most profound of human experiences: anxiety, stress, fear and the challenge of standing still in a rotating world. It is the aim of this author to present ‘Friday’ as a welcome, albeit belated, Acquarian commentary of considerable philosophical import made remarkable by its refreshing candour and enthusiasm to embrace often underused analytical resources in the spiritual teachings and indigenous theologies of both Occident and Orient. Continue reading

Murder of David Kato

Letters to the Editor, The Irish Times, Saturday 29th January 2011

A chara,

The brutal killing of David Kato (World News, January 28th) is a crime born of such wretched ignorance and appalling bigotry as to demand the full and immediate focus of our outrage.

In a month that has already seen the killings in Tucson, allegedly prompted by the militant fulminations of the Tea Party media machine, Kato’s murder throws an urgent light on the role of media in conducting public opinion and the risks that are run when intolerance informs their agenda.

The editor of Uganda’s Rolling Stone newspaper, which published the names and addresses of more than 100 Ugandan homosexuals, including Kato, protested yesterday that he did not want the public to attack “people who promote homosexuality” – he just wants the government to hang them. Continue reading

Let’s Kick Racism Out Of Football Commentators

Some incredibly colourful Ghanaian fans, seen here in marked contrast to their dull, monochrome and singularly uncolourful American counterparts who aren't colourful at all.

The curtain finally came down on the first ever African World Cup last night, bringing to a close four weeks of thrills, spills and, more memorable yet, the steady deluge of thinly-veiled racist stereotyping by commentators the English-speaking world over.

Anyone who is familiar with BBC’s coverage of the African Cup of Nations will have had fair warning of what would await the world’s TV audiences in South Africa. Veterans of the biennial African tournament were braced for repeated references to the ‘colour’, ‘passion’ and ‘hunger’ of the native fans, hampered by their ‘tactical naivete’, ‘erratic goalkeeping’ and ‘explosive temperament’. Needless to say, they didn’t disappoint.

BBC performed their usual baffling stunt of bringing in a black ex-player as a guest studio analyst to supposedly provide some sort of inside track on how football is played in Africa, despite said player having absolutely no affiliation with Africa, other than some distant ancestral lineage. Just as five-times England cap John Salako was wheeled out to give his thoughts on the African Cup of Nations in 2005, so was Clarence Seedorf, former Netherlands international and native of Surinam, a Dutch colony located towards the northern tip of South America, unveiled as the Beeb’s resident ‘non-Caucasian’ face. A more misguided sop to tokenism you couldn’t script.

The true anachronistic highlights, however, were to come from the commentators. First and foremost, it became quickly apparent that African fans and players would have exclusive rights to the term ‘colourful’ over the course of the tournament. The opening ceremony was, according to Jonathan Stevenson of BBC Sport, “the most colourful opening ceremony of all time”. Alan Shearer (BBC) felt that Cameroon would ‘bring a certain colour’ to the tournament, while Martin Tyler (ESPN), Graham Taylor (5 Live) and serial offender Clive Tyldsley (ITV) never missed an opportunity to extol the colour of the African contingent. Continue reading

Conscience and the Civil Partnership Bill

Oireachtas votes on Civil Partnership Bill today

Fr Vincent Twomey (Opinion, The Irish Times, June 29) argues that the absence of a free vote over the Civil Partnership Bill in the Oireachtas is a violation of individual conscience. He goes on to state that, should the Bill become law, it will force citizens to collude in what they believe in good conscience to be morally wrong. He decries the criticism that greeted the statement issued by the Irish Bishops’ Conference which, he claims, “effectively claimed that the church – in particular in the wake of the Ferns, the Ryan and the Murphy reports – should remain silent”. These charges, and the manner in which he presents them, demand a response.

Bemoaning the oppressive forces of the Party Whip and the ‘liberal-progressive media’, Fr Twomey wheels out the tired example of Nazi Germany which ‘crushed the consciences’ of its citizens as being somehow analogous. Resorting to such hyperbolic rhetoric serves little purpose other than to undermine Fr Twomey’s argument.

Politicians, journalists and clergy alike are citizens of this State and members of their communities. Each carry out important social functions in ensuring the health of our democracy and the quality of life of its people. Irish people enjoy the important liberty of being able to decide which politicians to vote for (if any), which media to listen to (if any) and which churches to attend (if any). Continue reading

Who is Wayne O’Donoghue?

Wayne O'Donoghue

Who is Wayne O’Donoghue to you? Read the Sunday World since the story broke and you see a callous infanticidal paedophile who is now enjoying his premature freedom by frolicking about under a false name with a sexy British girlfriend. Read the judgment of Justice Paul Carney, the trial judge asked to rule on the facts of the case, however, and you see a very different story almost disappointing in its lack of salacious detail. You see a teenage boy, a neighbour and friend of the Holohan family who treated Robert like a brother, whose clumsy actions gave rise to what the State Pathologist described as ‘light injuries… at the horseplay end of the scale’ and ultimately to an unintended, accidental and horrific outcome: the death of Robert Holohan. You see someone who got scared and, as is the unfortunate temptation when fear takes over, made the mistake of trying to cover up what he had done. You see a young man confused and overwhelmed, who subsequently confessed and pleaded guilty to manslaughter, who apologised repeatedly, who served the sentence handed down to him by the Courts of Law and who has been back before the courts to defend his reputation against the libellous claims published about him in a number of red-tops.

“Judges deal with issues”, Lord Justice Wall of the English Court of Appeal said at a conference on media and privacy law over the weekend, “and journalists deal with stories”. Who could argue? Yet the difference between the two representations of Wayne O’Donoghue runs deeper than the mere semantics of the judicial and tabloid worlds. Continue reading

Loss of a Legend

Sir Bobby Robson RIP

Sir Bobby Robson RIP

Sir Bobby Robson, the most popular man in English football,  died earlier this morning. Having successfully overcome cancer a staggering four times, Sir Bobby was diagnosed with terminal cancers in his lungs in 2007. His death marks the passing of one of sport’s true gentlemen and will be felt particularly here in Ireland, where he spent two years as part of the international management team.

I had the good fortune of meeting the man on his first engagement as international football consultant: a 3-0 win over Sweden on a bitterly cold March night at the old Lansdowne Road. Having wrangled myself a pass to the player’s lounge afterwards, I made a giddy circuit of the room, stopping schmoozing players for their photographs, autographs and the odd word of conversation. In a squad with few stars, it went without saying that the masses of snot-nosed children were concentrated in dense swarms around Robbie Keane, Shay Given and Damien Duff,  enabling my access to less celebrated heroes.

A ripple of oohs and ahhs announced the arrival of each new player from the dressing-room, tides of youngsters ebbing this way and that as one would arrive and another would be spotted the far side of the room. Bobby Robson managed to sneak in under the radar, but hadn’t even made it as far as the bar before he was surrounded by the gaggle of green-shirted youngsters jostling for position. My initial reaction was one of concern: it had been a particularly freezing night and he looked pinched despite his woollen coat and apt green scarf. I found myself surprised by all the extra lines in his face, so much more worn than the bright lights of camera flashes allowed, so haggard compared to that suntanned smile from the photos of Italia ’90 that I kept stored in my mind’s eye. The West Stand of Lansdowne Road is no place for a 73 year old on an icy night like this, I told myself.

My image of the frail pensioner was swiftly and gloriously shattered a moment later when one of the hair-gelled ten year olds shoved a match programme under Bobby’s nose,  loudly requesting that he sign it.

“I don’t sign anything for you ’til you say please” came the reply.

The boy gave a startled smirk, looking mildly disorientated before repeating that he wanted Bobby to sign the brochure for him.

“I know you want me to sign it and I’m telling you I ain’t going to sign anything unless you ask nicely and say please. Have a bit of manners”.

Chastened, the boy managed a considerably more polite effort. Bobby duly obliged.

“Now, there you go, that wasn’t so hard, was it?”

The boy walked away with his brochure in his hand and a few gruff Geordie words in his ear, probably too young to realise that he had just entered the exalted company of Gascoigne, Romario and the countless other young men to whom Bobby Robson had laid down the law. Suddenly the pinched frail old man standing before me was a proud, battle-hardened warrior, a man from the North East who’d seen more cold nights and cheeky youngsters than I’d had hot dinners.

“Excuse me Sir Bobby, would you mind if I got a photo with you please?”

“’Course I don’t mind son.”

A gentleman, legend and hero. Rest in peace Bobby.

Response to the Ryan Report

Letters to the Editor, The Irish Times, Thursday 25th June 2009

A chara,

Jim Beresford’s castigation of the shortcomings in the Ryan report (“Ryan taboo on warped sexual training of Brothers a cop-out”, Opinion, June 18th) made for compelling reading. Over the course of his article, he decries the commission’s failure to consider the reality of sadomasochistic sexuality, ritualised in the formation of Christian Brother novices, as a motivation for the appalling sexual violence committed against the boys of Artane, noting that “the authors of the Ryan report don’t even hint that there could have been a sexual motivation for such violence”. The low priority accorded by the commission to exploration of this phenomenon as a cause of abuse does, indeed, give cause for wonder.

Artane

One is inclined to conclude that rape is, by its nature, a crime which begins and ends in the sphere of sexuality – and that this would have been an obvious starting point for the commission’s search for answers.

Sociological inquiries by academics and human rights activists, however, suggest otherwise – in the case of all-male penal institutions, at least.

Continue reading